Debugging: It's all about finding Albuquerque.
secretGeek .:dot Nuts about dot Net:.
home .: about .: sign up .: sitemap .: secretGeek RSS

Debugging: It's all about finding Albuquerque.

i shoulda made a left toin at albakoiki
"I knew I shoulda taken that
left turn at Albuquerque!"

Rico Mariani has an excellent series about The History of Visual Studio.

There's one little 'detour' in Part 10 of the story, where Rico describes debugging.

I love his description, he's clearly delivered this bit many times. It's so polished it deserves to be quoted all on its own.

I was the debugger lead in the early 90s and I used to explain the utility of debuggers and debugging tools in this way: Imagine a program with a bug, it has been running along, everything is fine, everything is going wonderful, the flow of execution arrives at a point we'll call Albuquerque, where it turns right. Now as every Bugs Bunny fan knows, the correct thing to do at Albuquerque is to turn left. The program's decision to go right has led it down an incorrect path and sometime later we will observe a problem.

Now if we're very lucky "sometime later" will be very soon, like for instance it might be that we just de-referenced a null pointer and we're going to take an exception about 2 nanoseconds after the mistake. That's an easy bug to fix. On the other hand it could be that "turning right" was more subtle - maybe we corrupted a data structure in a minor way and it might be days before we can see an observable effect - that kind of bug is a nightmare.

Finding "Albuquerque" is what I call The Fundamental Problem of Debugging. The debugger provides you with tools (e.g. breakpoints) that allow you to stop execution while things were still good and slowly approach the point where things first went wrong. The debugger likewise provides you with tools to examine the state afterwards, hoping to find evidence of what went wrong in the recent past that will help you to see the origin. The callstack window is a great example of looking at the past to try to understand what might have already gone wrong.

To find the problem, you might start after the failure and try to look back, finding a previously unobserved symptom and moving closer to the original problem or you might start before the failure and try to move forward slowly, hopefully not overshooting the problem by too much. Or you might do a combination of these things. You might add assertions or diagnostic output to help you to discover sooner that things went wrong, and give you a view of the past. It's all about finding Albuquerque.

Rico nicely covers just about all the things you do, in the desperate search for that elusive bug.

Some say too much time in the debugger is a sign of a bad programmer.

The zero-debugging viewpoint says your code should be so well designed you can reason about it without having to step into it. Others says that the best way to avoid long debugging sessions is consistent use of assertions.

I'll do whatever I can to avoid the existence of bugs in the wild. I'll use any approach I can to cut down the necessity for a deep debugging session.

But all the same, debugging is powerful magic. I expect I'll give up the Joy of Debugging when you pry the debugger from my cold, dead hands.





'KristofU' on Fri, 06 Nov 2009 06:55:29 GMT, sez:

Murphy's Law for asserts :
The more an assert seems obvious and superfluous, the higher the chance that it will be triggered.



'Ben F Rayfield' on Fri, 06 Nov 2009 20:35:16 GMT, sez:

Theres a much easier way to find bugs...

If you are a person who writes bugs and fixes them later, then you are fixing the wrong bugs. Yourself is the bug that caused those bugs. The most effective way to fix that bug is to go learn logic, bayesian statistics, and things like that.

I would not take a code-generating software seriously if it generated code that contained bugs. A programmer is a code-generator.



'Boofus McGoofus' on Fri, 06 Nov 2009 21:30:59 GMT, sez:

First step in figuring out what legacy code does: run it through the debugger and watch what happens. Stepping through code is a great way to learn what it does. While that's not tough to do with pen and paper, it's even easier when the debugger does it for you.



'Vincent Vancalbergh' on Wed, 15 Jun 2011 15:10:06 GMT, sez:

It's for this reason alone that I abhor javascript or any other "hard to debug" platform. Like the "new" MS Dynamics NAV 2009 RTC experience. Luckily, the next version will feature an actual in-client debugger.

PS: I read the legal bit :D




name


website (optional)


enter the word:
 

comment (HTML not allowed)


All viewpoints welcome. But the right to delete any post for any reason is reserved. Don't make me do it. Aim for constructiveness. Comments may be republished, emailed to your loved ones or printed and used as toilet paper. Also, I get particularly nasty on comment spam. It's not worth even trying to post comment spam here -- your html is escaped, and your links are given a rel='nofollow'. By attempting to post a comment, you understand that if the comment is considered spam, at my absolute discretion, your IP address may be used as the target of a prolonged distributed denial of service attack. Your electricity might suddenly stop working. Your car tyres will go mysteriously flat. You will suffer permanent hairloss. Your dreams will be filled with terrifying monsters. And in any case I reserve the right to record and publish your IP address.

 

TimeSnapper is a life analysis system that stores and plays-back your computer use. It makes timesheet recording a breeze, helps you recover lost work and shows you how to sharpen your act.

 

NimbleText - FREE text manipulation and data extraction

NimbleText is a Powerful FREE Tool

Use it for:

  • extracting data from text
  • manipulating text
  • generating code

It makes you look awesome. Use it right now! Go on! Hurry! Don't walk, run!

 

Articles

Mind-boggling Demo of New Gaming Genre, aka Folder-Based Hangman, aka Fun with Recursion Mind-boggling Demo of New Gaming Genre, aka Folder-Based Hangman, aka Fun with Recursion
Got CSV in your javascript? Use agnes. Got CSV in your javascript? Use agnes.
I went to write down a book name and founded an internet empire instead. I went to write down a book name and founded an internet empire instead.
NimbleText: Origins NimbleText: Origins
The Windows 8 Mullet The Windows 8 Mullet
Cosby: spontaneous striped background generator Cosby: spontaneous striped background generator
Slides from WDCNZ: Live Coding Asp.net MVC3 Slides from WDCNZ: Live Coding Asp.net MVC3
MVC 3, MVC 3, "Third Times a Charm" references
Custom Errors in ASP.Net MVC: It couldn't be simpler, right? Custom Errors in ASP.Net MVC: It couldn't be simpler, right?
Anatomy of a Domain Hijacking, part 2: The Website Who Came In From The Cold Anatomy of a Domain Hijacking, part 2: The Website Who Came In From The Cold
Anatomy of a Domain Hijacking, part 1 Anatomy of a Domain Hijacking, part 1
secretGeek.net domain has been stolen. The site may go down. secretGeek.net domain has been stolen. The site may go down.
Boring article: 'untrusted domain' issue with SQL Server. Boring article: 'untrusted domain' issue with SQL Server.
Coding While You Commute Coding While You Commute
Test Driven Dentistry Is A Good Thing Test Driven Dentistry Is A Good Thing
The 'less crashy' release of NimbleText The 'less crashy' release of NimbleText
Rethinking Toolbars in Visual Studio (or any IDE) Rethinking Toolbars in Visual Studio (or any IDE)
Where shall we have lunch? Where shall we have lunch?
Setting up email for your microIsv Setting up email for your microIsv
The NO Visual Studio movement: Compiling .net projects in Notepad++ The NO Visual Studio movement: Compiling .net projects in Notepad++
ZeroOne: the editor for programmers who think in binary ZeroOne: the editor for programmers who think in binary
Mercurial workflow for personal projects (with a .net bias) Mercurial workflow for personal projects (with a .net bias)
I see you're using vim. Let me fix that for you. I see you're using vim. Let me fix that for you.
The worst recruitment spam I've ever read The worst recruitment spam I've ever read
A thank you I forgot to say A thank you I forgot to say
My new product, NimbleText, is live My new product, NimbleText, is live
Grabbing the free songs of Jonathan Coulton (with Powershell) Grabbing the free songs of Jonathan Coulton (with Powershell)
Using NimbleSet to compare lists Using NimbleSet to compare lists
Wanted: Wiki Lists (dot org) Wanted: Wiki Lists (dot org)
DOS on Dope: The last MVC web framework you'll ever need DOS on Dope: The last MVC web framework you'll ever need
JSON Query Languages: 5 special purpose editors JSON Query Languages: 5 special purpose editors
What then, is b? What then, is b?
SQLike: A simple editor SQLike: A simple editor
Yet Another BizPlan Generator. Yet Another BizPlan Generator.
HOT GUIDS: A hot or not site for guids HOT GUIDS: A hot or not site for guids
How does life get better? One tiny hack at a time. How does life get better? One tiny hack at a time.
24 things to do, and 100 things *not* to do (yet) for building a MicroISV 24 things to do, and 100 things *not* to do (yet) for building a MicroISV
Venture capital won't kill Jeff Atwood, it will only make him Jeffer. Venture capital won't kill Jeff Atwood, it will only make him Jeffer.
A handy workflow image for newbie mercurial users A handy workflow image for newbie mercurial users
Fractal Feedback, a diversion into recreational programming Fractal Feedback, a diversion into recreational programming
Hump-Jumping: How the Education of Computer Science can be Saved, err, maybe. Hump-Jumping: How the Education of Computer Science can be Saved, err, maybe.
Suggested User Experience Improvements for DiffMerge Suggested User Experience Improvements for DiffMerge
SQL Style Extensions for C# SQL Style Extensions for C#
The Movie Hollywood (And My Wife) Doesn't Want You To See: Weekend at Jacko's The Movie Hollywood (And My Wife) Doesn't Want You To See: Weekend at Jacko's
Sysi: the ultimate administrators toolkit Sysi: the ultimate administrators toolkit

Archives .: secretGeek :: Complete Archives
TimeSnapper -- Automated Screenshot Journal TimeSnapper.com    
Version 3.3: true productivity boost

Next Action NextAction
Managing the top of your mind

NimbleText -- World's Simplest Code GeneratorNimbleText -- World's Simplest Code Generator, Text Manipulator, Data Extractor

25 steps for building a Micro-ISV 25 steps for building a Micro-ISV
3 minute guides -- babysteps in new technologies: powershell, JSON, watir, F# 3 Minute Guide Series
Universal Troubleshooting checklist Universal Troubleshooting Checklist
Top 10 SecretGeek articles Top 10 SecretGeek articles
ShinyPower (help with Powershell) ShinyPower
Now at CodePlex

Realtime CSS Editor, in a browser RealTime Online CSS Editor
Gradient Maker -- a tool for making background images that blend from one colour to another. Forget photoshop, this is the bomb. Gradient Maker


[powered by Google] 


How to be depressed How to be depressed
You are not inadequate.



Recommended Reading


the little schemer


The Best Software Writing I
The Business Of Software (Eric Sink)

Recommended blogs

Jeff Atwood
Joseph Cooney
Phil Haack
Scott Hanselman
Julia Lerman
Rhys Parry
Joel Pobar
Thomas White
OJ Reeves
Eric Sink

Aggregated Links

proggit
dzone
hacker news
dot net kicks

Human Link Machines

interesting finds
a continuous learner's weblog
arjan's world
weekly link post

LinkedIn profile
LogEnvy - event logs made sexy
Computer, Unlocked. A rapid computer customization resource
PC Smart Buys - Computer Hardware in Australia
 
home .: about .: sign up .: sitemap .: secretGeek RSS .: © Leon Bambrick 2006 .: privacy

home .: about .: sign up .: sitemap .: RSS .: © Leon Bambrick 2006 .: privacy